Random thoughts... snippets of life in rural New England
Published on August 26, 2005 By HC1240 In Writing
Raising Cain

Abel drew in a deep breath as the scent of the fatted lamb rose in the air. He reflected on how gracious the Lord had been to his family. After his parents’ disobedience, the Lord could have struck them dead on the spot, but He hadn’t done that. Instead He had brought them here, to this new land, and provided for their needs. Abel had heard stories about the magnificent Garden from his parents, but he was happy just to live here. The mountains painted a backdrop that was perfect for sunsets; the way the pink and purple hues of evening light cascaded against the ridge at dusk was like nothing Abel had ever seen.

The sacrifice seemed such a small way to show the Lord his appreciation. God had done so much for his family – surely there must be something more Abel could do in return. This was what God had asked for, though, and so Abel had selected the choicest lamb from his flock to offer before the Lord. He had examined each animal with great care, and had finally settled on this one. Of all the sheep in his flock, it was the best. He hoped the Lord would be pleased with it.

“Well it just figures you beat me here … anything to show up your brother.” Abel was jerked out of his reflection by his brother’s snarl. He looked up to see Cain glaring at him.

“I only just got here, Cain … besides, it’s not like this is a contest, ya know.” Abel was so often confused by his brother. Cain had a restless spirit. He was never satisfied, and always seemed to be competing with Abel. The gentler of the two, Abel longed for peace in their relationship. He wished for once they could just hang out – go fishing together, maybe skip some stones across the brook’s surface, talk about what they hoped their future would be like. He wanted to share with Cain his dream of someday taking Tamara as his wife, of having his own home and making a family with her. For now, he kept all of these things to himself. Cain was too wrapped up in himself to think about anyone else. Abel missed the days when he and Cain had played together as children. He hoped this was a phase that his brother would grow out of – that whatever was bothering Cain would pass and they could become friends again. Surely as they matured individually, perhaps their relationship would mature as well.

With a heavy sigh Abel put some more wood onto the fire. He nodded toward Cain. “Is your offering ready?”

“What’s it to you? It’s ready … ready as it’ll ever be anyway.” Cain mixed some of the course ground flour he’d brought with a little oil and incense. Once the paste was made, he carelessly tossed the mixture onto the altar. Soon the pleasant aroma of the offering filled the air. Abel closed his eyes and breathed deeply, taking in the sweet smell.

Cain wiped his hands against each other to rub off the residual powder and addressed Abel gruffly. “Are we done then?”
His worship interrupted once again, Abel nodded and watched as Cain turned on his heel and stormed off. He wished he could do something to make his brother feel better, but every time he tried, it seemed Cain only got angrier. He would leave it alone and let the Lord deal with it; He always knew best.

The Lord looked with favor upon Abel’s offering. He knew that Abel had brought the firstborn of his flock in recognition that everything he had was from the Lord, and that it all belonged to Him. Abel had offered his sacrifice in faith, with thanksgiving, and the Lord was pleased.

God was not pleased with Cain’s offering, however, because He knew Cain had been merely going through the motions. He had not put any thought or care into his offering, and the Lord saw that Cain’s heart was not in it – he didn’t care about the offering or what would please God at all. The only thing Cain cared about was Cain. His selfishness was like a disease, damaging the quality of his life.

When Cain saw that the Lord had looked with favor upon Abel’s offering, but had not done so with his own, he became very angry. He stared at the ground and tried to control his breathing in an attempt to hide his anger from the Lord – something he should have known wasn’t possible.

The Lord spoke to Cain, “Why are you angry? Why is your face downcast? If you do what is right, will you not be accepted? But if you do not do what is right, sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must master it.”
Cain would have done well to take God’s words and heed them, but instead the rage inside him took control. It simmered and bubbled until it came to a full boil deep within his heart, molten lava threatening to burst through the surface and destroy everything in its path. Cain paced back and forth, struggling to contain the resentment burning inside. Jealousy coursed through his veins, seeking an outlet. In that instant, a plan began to form in Cain’s mind. Emotion ruled his mind and the pieces came together, almost without thought.

“Abel! Where are you? Brother!” Cain’s voice shook just a bit as he summoned his brother.

“Coming … just a minute.” Abel dumped some sand over the last of the fire’s glowing embers. He turned in the direction of his brother’s voice and wondered what Cain wanted.

Cain came jogging up the path and clapped a hand on Abel’s shoulder. “Hey … yesterday I was out in the field and this gorgeous doe came out of the woods to graze. She was so pretty! You should have seen her.”

“Yeah? Sorry I missed it.”

Cain chose his next words very carefully. “I know how much you love watching the deer, Abel. Why don’t we go out to the field and see if we can catch her again? Don’t the deer sometimes follow the same path each day? Like a routine? Let’s go out to the field and see is we can spot her … I’m tellin’ ya, she was a beauty!”

Abel was an expert with animals. He didn’t need help in tracking a deer, but he was excited that Cain wanted to do something with him. This was just what he’d been hoping for! Maybe this would be the start of a new relationship for he and his brother. Anxiously, Abel agreed and the two set off for the field.

As they approached the field, Cain gasped and pointed excitedly. “Look! Over there! Can you see her?”

Abel strained his eyes, but didn’t see anything. The only movement he sensed was that of the grass bending in the wind. He kept searching the field, his eyes scanning back and forth, looking intently for the doe.

With Abel’s attention occupied trying to spot the deer, Cain found the large hunk of slate he had left in the field earlier. It was heavy, and he awkwardly lifted it to his chest with both hands. He held it there in one arm and ran the fingers of his other hand over its rough coolness. The stone’s color was black as the evil in Cain’s heart.

With a murderous cry, Cain hefted the stone up over his head and charged straight for Abel. “Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah!”

Abel snapped his head around and his mouth dropped open in horror as he realized Cain’s intent. He tried to dodge his brother, but wasn’t quick enough. Cain’s eyes were filled with a bloodthirsty gleam as he brought the slate down over Abel’s head with a sick thud. Abel slumped to the ground and Cain smiled as he watched a crimson flow of blood gush from the back of his brother’s head. Satisfied with the carnage, Cain kicked his brother in the leg and left the field.

As he was walking the path back to their camp, Cain was startled by the Lord’s voice. “Where is your brother, Abel?”

Cain immediately became defensive and indignant. “How should I know? Am I my brother’s keeper?” He continued to move forward along the path, as if his indifference would disguise his guilt.

“What have you done? Listen! Your brother’s blood cries out to me from the ground.” Cain stopped walking.

“Now you are under a curse and driven from the ground, which opened its mouth to receive your brother’s blood from your hand. When you work the ground, it will no longer yield its crops to you. You will be a restless wanderer on the earth.”

Confronted with his crime and its resulting curse, Cain responded not with remorse, but with self-pity. He whined about his punishment: “This is too much, God! It’s more than I can bear. Today you are driving me from the land, the only home I’ve ever known, and I will be hidden from your presence; I will roam aimlessly on the earth, and whoever finds me is just gonna kill me.”

“Not so; if anyone kills Cain, he will suffer vengeance seven times over.” Then God put a mark on Cain so that no one who found him would kill him, and in God’s mercy, the life of a murderer was spared.

Comments
on Aug 26, 2005
Yeah, why was God not all warm a fuzzy about Cain minor altercation?
on Aug 26, 2005
Well... I could just say it's historical fiction, so I get to make part of it up... but that would be a cop out, and I'm not into those.

I do believe, from study, that it was all about Cain's heart. I have a friend who believes that God rejected Cain's offering because it was not a blood sacrifice, but I honestly don't think that's it.

The Hebrew word for "offering" that verses 4 and 5 say both men brought is the same ("minchah"), and is the same word used later in Leviticus to describe the proper and right kind of offering one makes to God. Add to that the fact that this word is used to describe a general offering, and not a sin offering ("chata'ah" (so no blood was needed for remission of sins)), and I'm led to believe that is wasn't the offering itself that was important, it was the heart of the man that brought it.

Looking in Chapters 3 and 4 it says that Cain just took "some" of the fruits of the soil, he didn't much care which, or that it was firstfruits - in fact, he probably wanted to keep the best for himself. Abel brought the choicest... it's reasonable that Cain would bring an offering of fruit - he was a farmer. Abel would bring animal - he was a shepherd. It doesn't say that God simply rejected the offering... He rejected the man. "The Lord looked with favor on Abel and his offering, but on Cain and his offering he did not look with favor." God was looking at the heart of each man... the offering was indicative of the heart. Abel sought out the best because he loved God, and wanted to give the best. Cain grabbed whatever was handy because he was simply going through the motions. Heb. 11:4 says, "By faith Abel offered God a better sacrifice than Cain did. By faith he was commended as a righteous man, when God spoke well of his offerings. And by faith he still speaks, even though he is dead." Bottom line, Abel had a regenerate heart, and Cain did not... and that was the reason for the rejection.

Cain is mentioned three other times, outside of Genesis. As I mentioned above, Hebrews talks of Cain's rejection in terms of lack of faith, John alludes to the fact that Cain's acts are a result of his evil disposition (1 John 3:12), and Jude seems to imply that Cain's motivation was greed (Jude 1:11), and so the rejection. Makes me think of all the times that God spoke to the Israelites about offering all their sacrifices... yet without sincerity. I think Isaiah outlines it pretty well.

I'm sure there are a myriad of opinions out there, but I think going back to the original Hebrew always helps to clarify.... and of course, interpreting the passage in light of other Scripture.

Ok.. that was longer than I intended.... The bottom line for me is based in 1 Samuel 16:7: "...For the Lord does not see as man sees; for man looks at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart."
on Aug 26, 2005
Good Job Heather. Both the story and explanation. The bottom line is eactly that.... God looks into our heart to see our motives. The sacrifice is secondary.
on Aug 27, 2005
Yeah, why was God not all warm a fuzzy about Cain minor altercation?

Not sure I understand your question, Aeryck... did I answer it?

on Aug 31, 2005
Hey HC, I thought we talked about not making a conclusion from non evidence.

You cannot say that Cain kept the first fruits for himself because it does not say that. It says that he took fruit from the ground and just because it doesn't say "first" doesn't mean he did not do that. You said rightly (and I agree totally) that the main reason is the attitude of the heart and we have to leave it at that. But there is, as you know, another way of looking at this using Hebrew 12:24 which says, "And to Jesus the mediator of the new covenant and to the blood of sprinkling that speaks better things than that of Abel."

Abel's sacrifice was that of the old covenant and Jesus self sacrifice was that of the new. Comparing the old way of dealing with sin and the new way which is not the blood of bulls and goats but his own blood shed for us once and for all.

I happen to believe also that God who is a God of second chances as you know gave Cain another shot. Take a look at Gen 4:7 in which God states, "If you do well, shall you not be accepted? and if you do not well, sin lies at the door. And unto you shall be his desire and you shal rule over him."

I think God was saying that Cain was still covered in sin and he needed to give a blood sacrifice to be cleansed as did his brother. He's promised restored fellowship here if he does. Abel had that assurance of being cleansed by bringing in his blood sacrifice something Cain had yet to do and we all know how sin has a way of growing on us.

Actually nothing is said in Genesis or Heb 11:4 as to why Abel's sacrifice in itself was more acceptable, though the fact that it involved blood sacrifice is significant by looking at 12:24 and Gen 4:7 a bit more closely. But, I admit, the debate does rage on here. We are in agreement that it's not the sacrifice but the heart that God is concerned with. Let us always remember that his desire is our hearts. Let's make sure his desire is ours also.
on Sep 01, 2005


Hebrew 12:24 which says, "And to Jesus the mediator of the new covenant and to the blood of sprinkling that speaks better things than that of Abel."

I still stand with my original position. This is speaking about the blood of Abel, not the blood of his sacrifice.

*jumping off the merry-go-round*

Yes... we have talked about it... and talked... and talked... . I believe in the end we agreed to disagree. I can live with that.

on Sep 01, 2005
Going with your thinking I'm still not getting why Abel's blood was good to start with in contrast to Christ's blood being better especially in light of the enire chapter of Hebrews 12 which compares the Old Covenant and the New.

But another thought.....remember that verse in I John 3:12 which you mentioned above but did not quote? Well it says there that Cain "slew" his brother.....well the word "slew" we learned from our Pastor when he did the sermon series on this book is "sphazo" in Greek which basically means to cut one's throat. Remember? I'm thinking here that Cain was in his rage saying to God...."you wanna sacrifice, here's a sacrifice and he cut his own brother's throat. I don't think it's a coincidence that was the method of death used and it gives better meaning to Heb 12:24 as well if you think of it in the light of 1 John 3:12. While a rock to the head sounds easier a cut throat definitely would draw the blood that would be sprinkled upon the ground as well.

Beside, what sisters don't disagree once in a while. We can't always be on the same side; what fun is that????



on Sep 01, 2005
But another thought.....remember that verse in I John 3:12 which you mentioned above but did not quote? Well it says there that Cain "slew" his brother.....well the word "slew" we learned from our Pastor when he did the sermon series on this book is "sphazo" in Greek which basically means to cut one's throat. Remember? I'm thinking here that Cain was in his rage saying to God...."you wanna sacrifice, here's a sacrifice and he cut his own brother's throat. I don't think it's a coincidence that was the method of death used and it gives better meaning to Heb 12:24 as well if you think of it in the light of 1 John 3:12. While a rock to the head sounds easier a cut throat definitely would draw the blood that would be sprinkled upon the ground as well.

I can go with this. Hey... I'm teachable The story was written three years before I heard the sermon... before I actually started STUDYING, even...



Going with your thinking I'm still not getting why Abel's blood was good to start with in contrast to Christ's blood being better especially in light of the enire chapter of Hebrews 12 which compares the Old Covenant and the New.

And I quote from our e-mail exchange of January.... we began debating whether the blood was from Abel's sacrifice, or his own blood...

"I don't think Heb. 12:24 is talking about Abel's sacrifice at all. I think it's referring to Abel's own blood. It doesn't say "the blood of Abel's sacrifice", it says "the blood of Abel". Looking at context, back in Heb. 11:4 it talks of Abel still speaking, even though he is dead - his blood crying out from the ground, and Luke 11:50-51 goes to that also, even naming him as a prophet because of it. Abel's blood cried out for justice and retribution... but Jesus' blood is even greater in that it is about more than injustice... it's about forgiveness and reconciliation. Jesus' blood speaks a "better word" because it goes beyond getting justice, straight to the heart of mercy and love - resulting in atonement. I know there is controversy over this (whether this verse refers to the blood of Abel or that of his sacrifice), and while I can see the other viewpoint, I'm not convinced it's accurate in light of everything else I've looked at on this. I'm guessing that if studied Bible scholars can't agree... neither of us is going to convince the other of an opposing viewpoint "
And from another e-mail sent that same day (from me to you):

"I do see the point of view of Hebrews that you mentioned... I can actually see both sides, and you're right... both sides have to do some assuming. I'm giving up for now... ... thankful that in the end, it really doesn't matter much in the grand scheme of things. Jesus' blood made all the difference, and is superior to either the blood of Abel, or the blood of Abel's sacrifice. For me, I will continue to offer Him a sacrifice of praise... and to do my best to make my life a living sacrifice for Him, always keeping in mind what He gave up for me. Such love!"

My position remains the same... as well as my sentiment.... It's fun initially... but after we keep saying the same things over and over again, and looking at the same positions, it's not so much fun. I'd rather tackle something new... or focus on how to apply the principles to my life, rather than quibble over things that don't really matter in the grand scheme of things. *grins*


on Jan 11, 2006
HC...I agree with you about the condition of the heart....

Anyway, very nice. I don't think I will ever read the Biblical account again without these images in my mind.

I've never thought about historical fiction about Biblical stories...what a great idea! Do a bunch of them and get published!!

You obviously are doing the research for it too! WOW!
on Jan 11, 2006
HC...I agree with you about the condition of the heart....

Anyway, very nice. I don't think I will ever read the Biblical account again without these images in my mind.

I've never thought about historical fiction about Biblical stories...what a great idea! Do a bunch of them and get published!!

You obviously are doing the research for it too! WOW!

Do a bunch and get published? Where have I heard that before? *grins* Thanks, girl. Glad you liked it.